Showing posts with label property taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label property taxes. Show all posts

Saturday, February 5, 2011

A Downtown Lamentation

   Today marks the ever-advancing end of an era for downtown Savannah.  There was a time when people went downtown to for things they needed - shoe repair, a new hat, groceries, prescriptions, etc.  Nowadays, people go downtown for the sake of going downtown.  They idly browse upscale boutiques for items that people want, but no one actually needs.  Where you once had furniture stores, you now have designer furniture stores - edgy, modern, expensive.  Where once was a venerable department store, now you have luxury condos.  Inside the old discount store, a Gap.  You see where I am going with this.  Useful consumption replaced with vice consumption.  They say it is the downside of gentrification - area becomes desirable, greedy landlords raise rents, greedy city raises taxes, and so on.  Eventually, the only type of store that CAN be downtown is a luxury boutique or a corporate chain. 
Broughton Street then, more than likely taken inside the old-fashioned traveler's rate Gilbert Hotel.
Original image from www.quaintplaces.com

Broughton Street today, taken street level outside the luxury boutique hotel Marshall House.
Original image from the blog www.simplyjessie.com

   The reason this problem compounds today is because it is the last business day of Polk's Market in downtown Savannah.  Polk's was one of the last vestiges of commerce life as it once was downtown.  From its beginnings in City Market decades ago, Polk's came to be on Liberty Street in a simple 1950s large open warehouse.  Its vast expanse was loaded with baskets of fresh-picked produce and flowers.  It was an ideal place for not only local cafes to select their fresh ingredients, but for the locals residing in the mostly-residential neighborhood that Polk's also called home. 
Polk's soon-to-be former home on the corner of Liberty and Houston.
   This place was not a hokey tourist trap, it was not an upscale gourmet market - it was honest and straight forward.  Why then, would a concept as pure as "fresh produce for people" serve to be a bad business model after 80 years of success?  Aside from the bad weather cited by many small farmers, the owner of Polk's mentions something all too familiar in recent years: "the rising cost of doing business downtown". 

   Now, a lot of people have gathered that the economy has plummeted and the real estate market has collapsed, but the most optimistic people in this city are most of the landlords and tax assessors.  Many of them seem to believe it is still jolly old 2005.  While there have been significant drops in commercial buildings for sale (maybe they only cost 1 million instead of 2 million now), it still greatly limits who can buy that building.  Private investment companies and corporate chains could plunk down that sort of money, but then the cycle starts over with the tenant whose rent seems to go up as sales go up.  Two things need to be examined here:
   1) How can we establish a path for a person in Savannah looking to start their own business downtown to be able to either purchase the building in which they would set up shop, or protect them from skyrocketing rents (which not only harms the business owner, but drives up costs all throughout the neighborhood)?
   2) How can we keep property taxes within the realm of what the fair market value is of these buildings?

   That second part takes a little bit of faith.  Obviously, the higher the tax commissioner's office sets the property taxes, the more money they are pulling in.  Personally, I am paying taxes on a $230,000.00 house that only has a fair market value of $190,000.00.  Now, a few years back I could have easily unloaded the house for $230,000.00.  My Realtor no longer thinks so, and guessing by the houses in the neighborhood that have gone up on the market, my neighbors don't think so either.  The tax commissioner seems to think so, maybe he will pay me $40,000.00 above fair market value for my house? 

   I was told recently that I can't reasonably expect the tax commissioner to re-evaluate every property every time there is a dip in the real estate market.  The property owner is constantly having to re-evaluate, so I personally do not see why we should expect any less of the tax commissioner's office.  No one expects or likes to pay more for something than it is worth (and haven't we all?), but when it comes down to your bottom line, rents and taxes can mean the difference between staying open and closing up shop.  If all continues down the same path, the future of downtown Savannah is one of chain stores and exclusive upscale boutiques.  One destroys the authenticity of the neighborhood, and the other alienates a majority of the town's citizens. 

   It is not right that the Colonial Historic District in Savannah should be the place that everyday citizens feel the least connection to.  A neighborhood is not made up of buildings, but of people.  The era of walking into a locally owned shop to purchase reasonably priced, useful goods downtown should not ever become something that we lose.  Having worked in a "mom-n-pop" on Broughton Street, I can attest that the city made it very difficult to actually do business.  When you hand your city over to out of town developers and large corporations, you lose that "people" aspect that made the neighborhood what it was in the first place.  The shop where I worked on Broughton Street sold vintage furniture, salvaged house parts and hardware.  We moved further south.  Our old store is now an upscale furniture and design showroom, an "ultra-chic and savvy" lounge, and bountiful opportunity for you to have an open floor plan loft upstairs. 

   As Polk's shuts down on this overcast, drizzly Saturday, downtown Savannah now has one more building that people can walk past and say "I remember when that was...".  In a generation or so, no one will even say that.  The building where Polk's existed is owned by Mazol Realty.  A Google search brought up nothing too relevant under that name.  While searching public records, I found that Mazol Realty Co. Inc. is headquartered in a mansion at 226 Huntington Street in Savannah.  The property card lists it as a single family home.
   So long, Polk's.  You will be missed.