Showing posts with label Mayor Otis Johnson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mayor Otis Johnson. Show all posts

Monday, September 12, 2011

Savannah, Get Slapped Quick!

The "Welcome Party" of City Manager Rochelle
Small-Toney.  Not pictured- thousands of dollars
spent on useless shit, like custom-engraved
wine glasses, shrimp cocktail, and a
chocolate fountain.  Glad all of Savannah's
back-breakers are doing well enough to foot the
bill for this party.  Oh, you were not invited?
Well, I can easily say I have taken a hiatus from blogging.  Also, I have used this time to become far more cynical.  This is mostly due to the fact that every time I look at the Savannah Morning News, I see so much sheer fuckery going on in City Hall, that one is left feeling silly blogging about it.  You see, in Savannah's City Hall, the corruption does not need to be peeled away in layers by a blogger; it is printed right there in black and white on the newspaper page!  I could say, "Mayor Johnson threatens so-and-so again!" or, "City Manager threatens so-and-so again!" (see the pattern?), but what is the purpose of me doing so when we have such truths printed in the newspaper for all of the city to see?  They are basically rubbing their dirty toilet paper under our noses and telling us there is nothing we can do about it.  After all, a slap on the wrist from the higher-ups in the state is just the cost of doing business in a backward broken system.

And where is our "state-owned" news media during all of this mayhem (Lesley Conn excluded)?  News media has a way of making us lose our shit over just about anything, so why are they not taking active steps in this town to inform the people, and really drive home, just what is going on?  We have initiated impeachment proceedings for American Presidents over crap not too much worse than what goes on weekly in City Hall!  Oh, I forget.  Every televised news media outlet in Savannah seems to have an obligation to keep everything fluffy and light!  After all, if a tourist catches a broadcast from their hotel room television, we wouldn't want them to see what this town really is, would we?  However, each broadcast will shamelessly open with the leading shooting/murder of the day, but we can't follow up with the condescension of our Mayor, or the shut-the-fuck-up mentality of his cronies?  I guess violence and homicide are just the sorts of things we have come to expect in grand, old Savannah, especially since our local government cannot come up with a solution to the problem regardless of our ever-increasing costs of living in this town!  Pay more to be more unhappy; great business model, City Hall!

And speaking of business model - I know I have said it before; I don't believe that any practice that would fail in running a business should be expected to pass in running a local government.  A business manager does not lay off employees and then redecorate her office with the money she saved.  A business owner does not decide who gets hired based on that person's skin color.  An investor's board does not get to doll out investor money amongst themselves while the investors are barely making ends meet!  And sure as shit, a business facing a multi-million dollar lawsuit does not decide to give themselves all raises AFTER laying off the employees and jacking the hell out of the retail value the customers are expected to pay!

So here we have it, a fucked business on the verge of selecting a new CEO and board, which will have influence in appointing a permanent manager.  Most of us are the investors in this business.  We fall under the following categories:  There are the wealthy investors, who either live out of state or city limits, or live here only seasonally- transplanted by some notion of quaintness.  There are the poor investors, who will statistically either choose to have no say in who runs the business, or will just re-elect whatever existing members they can because they don't do research out of apathy.  Then there are the middle-class investors, who either live out of city limits yet work here, or actually live in city limits and sweat their asses off every day to make ends meet.  Then there are the customers - the tourists - who like most customers, will still travel far and wide to shop at a chain store and hurt both the local and state economy, but they don't give a shit because they turn around and go home to where they would rather be anyway.  All the while the upper management has their fuck-ups broadcast to the masses and responds with, "Let's just raise the retail values and pass that cost on to everyone else!"

So what will it be investors?  It looks as if it all falls into the hands of that weakest group among us - the middle-income investors who live and work within city limits.  Who will be our CEO, manager and chairmen?  We need to pick some good people - people who aren't recycled.  I hate to say it, and take it as you wish, if Savannah, Georgia were a business, it would already be throwing a closing sale.

Friday, February 25, 2011

The "Democratic" Process

   Rochelle Small-Toney is the new City Manager of Savannah, Georgia.  Mayor Pro Tem Edna Jackson has declared this a victory for the democratic process and hopes that the city will now just, how did she put it, basically shut up their complaining and accept it.  A tidbit for Jackson; if you have to ask the people to to just forget about it and move on to another issue, then I would have to suggest that maybe your democratic process did not yield a democratic result. 

   One of the most important parts of a democracy is a system of checks and balances.  Without those, Edna, a democracy is not a democracy.  A majority power has the ability in a government system to enforce its will upon everyone.  These checks and balances are a way to reach compromise between the majority and the minority to ensure that both sides are heard and considered.

   Now, it can be argued that a democratic republic is the finest form of government there is.  It could also be argued that a dictatorship is the best.  In a vacuum inhabited only by people with the unwavering intention to do what is best for all of the people, both of those arguments would be correct.  If, however, those in charge use the opportunity to further their own agendas with a "here's how it is, now accept it" approach, well...you see where I am going with this.  It is a democracy by name only, but no different than most countries ruled by a powerful majority that calls all of the shots in its own favor. 

   Let's take a look at Edna Jackson's democracy:
  •  The CM search comes down to two candidates, neither of which being the candidate who received the most positive feedback from government employees.  That candidate was Pat DiGiovanni, who also happens to have "white" skin.  When the four white council members voiced concern that the candidate who received the most positive feedback (appx 49-5 positive returns from city employees) was not in the final two, Edna commented that the four white members were following the process until the white candidate was not selected.  
"I'm sorry," she said. "But we followed a democratic process."
  •  City council voted unanimously that any city manager is required to be bonded at one-million dollars on January 26.  This is a bond that is in place to protect the city should the City Manager make a horrible and irresponsible mistake.  Once disclosed that Small-Toney was not able to secure a one-million dollar bond for reasons unknown, "some of the council members questioned whether it should be a requirement".  Edna Jackson commented that the council would need more time to read the 4-sentence long ordinance before making a decision. 
  • A compromise put forth by Stuber, as a means to solve the CM search issue in the most honest manner possible, called for:
    • Suspension of the search until after the November elections.
    • A new acting City Manager (who meets all qualifications) would take the job until that time, agreeing not to run for the permanent position.
    • Small-Toney would return to her previous job of Asst. City Manager of Public Development, and would be able to apply for the permanent position of City Manager again, when the search began anew following November elections.
        • This compromise covers a few important concerns.  It would allow the city manager search to be carried out by a new Mayor and a new Council, as opposed to a potentially-outgoing group.  Basically, those who would have to work with the CM for years to come would be the ones making the decision.
        • A person holding the post temporarily who is qualified, yet has no intention to run for the permanent post, would allow for an unbiased acting manager who would have no political influence on Mayor, Council, or anyone else in the city for that matter.
        • Small-Toney, if in the meantime she were able to fulfill requirements making her eligible, would be able to run again for the position.  
Edna Jackson voted no to this compromise, calling it a "slap in the face" to Small-Toney.  Van Johnson, Clifton Jones, Mary Osborne, and Mayor Johnson also voted no.
  • City council meets to discuss options for selecting the new City Manager "that will demonstrate a clear majority and bring a vote not divided along racial lines".  Edna declares that she will purposefully avoid talking to any other members of city council until they can "come to some resolution."
   Edna Jackson's idea of the democratic process comes across somewhat flawed, I must say.  Something such as "I am all for democracy as long as I get my way, I won't compromise, and I won't talk to you until you agree with me.  If you never do agree with me, that is fine because I am voting with the majority."  That, of course, is not a direct quote.  People being corrupt and backward typically do not do so in such a straightforward manner.

   All of the compromises suggested seemed to have merit (except for Clifton Jone's compromise of "let's just go ahead and hire Small-Toney {the most absurd one, which [wouldn't you know] turned out to be the one they chose!}).  That was as many parenthesis and brackets as I could possibly use.  However, none of these compromises - these hints of true democracy in which two disagreeing forces find common ground - were good enough for Edna Jackson, or a majority of council.  Now, the rest of us have a supreme ruler who was forced upon us.  For those of us who don't give a damn what color the City Manager is (because we know that the financial future of our town is more important than a civil rights pissing match), we are now left to wonder if the person with a questionable past, who received almost as many negative reviews as positive from city employees, who kept secret her failure to obtain a bond, and refuses to open up about the situation to put it to bed, is REALLY the best person to control Savannah's blank check book!  That is the concern now, but none of that matters.  We made history.  Savannah has its first black, female City Manager.  That is all that seems to really matters in this town.  We once would strive to boast about our progress in the arena of economic growth, industrial growth, infrastructure maintenance, and the like.  Now, our boast of progress is the color of skin of the official chosen to oversee the aforementioned.  Ironically, that seems to be a step backwards to me.  I will sum up the situation with these two quotes:

The new [black] majority, too, must consider a different approach, says Sam Fulwood III, a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress in Washington, D.C., a think tank studying race, diversity and population changes.
If new leadership works from a "turnabout is fair play" standpoint, it will serve only to further entrench racial animosities, he said.
"I think that is the fear and the instinct," he said. "I think that is misguided and dangerous...if it resorts to payback, it's going to delay getting to compromise."  
from SMN article by Lesley Conn

At one point during discussion, three council members say, the mayor told them that when former City Manager Michael Brown was hired about 15 years ago, the only black candidate didn't make it into final consideration. Although the three couldn't agree on the mayor's exact words, his conclusion was "it's our turn now."
from SMN article by Lesley Conn.  Original photo by Richard Burkhart

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

Political Roundup

   For anyone who has been blissfully enjoying life in Savannah for the past month, allow be to bring you down a bit by bringing you up to date.

2/3/11, city manager candidate Alfred Lott's ongoing legal issues are made public.  Affion Public got big bucks to find the "best of the best" candidates, but somehow missed this.  Clifton Jones thinks it is reason enough to go ahead and hire Small-Toney outright.  (after all, intimidation, discrimination and defamation have no place in City Hall).

2/3/11, Tony Thomas continues to call it as he sees it, making him probably one of a handful of modern-day politicians who is not afraid of hurting someone's feelings.  I would imagine 1960s chips would taste pretty stale by now.

2/7/11, city council members and the Mayor prepare for their annual retreat amid increasing racial infighting and name-calling.  Ever been sitting in a car on a long ride with someone you are mad at? 

2/8/11, Carol Bell, director of Central Services, may be dropping her discrimination claim against Small-Toney.  Bell is black, Small-Toney is black, Small-Toney chose a white woman over Bell for a job, and all aforementioned people are over 50 years of age.  I was not going to include this article, but it was too absurd to ignore.  Think of it as your commercial break.  In fact, don't read it; I will sum it up nicely in one run-on sentence.  Black female boss over 50 hires white female over 50 instead of other black female over 50, therefore other black female over 50 files complaint against black female boss over 50 on the basis of racial, sex, and age discrimination.  You are now less intelligent. 

2/15/11, James Dewberry will run for Mayor again.

2/15/11, city manager candidate Alfred Lott drops out of the running, opting to live a secret life at a secret job in D.C.  Small-Toney is now the only candidate for the position (funny how things work out!).

2/16/11, though Small-Toney has no competition, she may not be chosen by default. Also, all cloudy aspects up to this point are hashed out, and Jones and Osborne prove that it is easier to sink your heels in than it is to try to pay attention and come up with something productive.

2/21/11, Police end the McCarthy-esque investigation into uncovering who leaked the information that Small-Toney could not and did not have a bond.

   Meanwhile, in Blog Land, there is a growing movement of insight on the NFBPA.  Racial tension became unavoidable in this discussion after Mayor Johnson flung open the door with his quote about wanting a black City Manager.
   Also on A Concerned Citizen's blog, the list of NFPBA members of the Savannah Chapter.  There would be no reason to make mention of this, other than the fact that the list disappeared from the chapter's website following this entire City Hall debacle.  Removing content is an extremely dicey move to make when trying to put forward the appearance that there is "nothing to see here".  Just ask Sarah Palin after Gabrielle Giffords was shot. 

   The fact of the matter is this; all of those articles printed above are just a fraction of what has transpired since we began the seemingly straightforward task of finding a City Manager.  It has become an issue of race which sickened me at first, but you know what?  Maybe it is about time we were forced to discuss this. 

   I picture these situations arising in the same manner that causes car accidents due to over-correction; driver veers slightly off road and in response, jerks the wheel hard in the opposite direction pulling them into the oncoming lane, or flipping the vehicle.  In that context, we had organizations come about leading up to, and during the civil rights movement in the mid-century.  Necessary at those times, some of them have actually become proponents of the same type of polarization they were meant to eradicate.  What began with noble roots of allowing equal rights to black people now expresses dialogue of advancing black people over white people.  Any way you cut it, preferring one over another, aiding one over another, advancing one over another on the basis of skin color is unethical, immoral and illegal.  That color does not matter more than the action itself. 

   If you think I am being cynical or jumping to conclusions, I refer you again to every link at the top of this post.  The Mayor thinks he will be making history and breaking barriers by selecting a black city manager.  What happened to finding the most qualified person?  Does the Mayor not realize the doors this opens for any white candidate who was not selected to sue this city?  Mr. Mayor, I don't think you have watched the Broadway musical "Avenue Q", but one very true line from that production states "bigotry has never been exclusively white."  A world without white power and without black power; that was the hope of the Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr.  What would he think of the NFPBA?  What would he think of the movement he died for? 

Friday, February 11, 2011

A Sad Day For Savannah

Meet our city leaders. Instead of "Yes" or "No", it could easily read "White" or "Black".  Tony Thomas voted "Yes" but his bulb was out, which is OK because he can just shout it out without a bulb.  He's cool like that.
Original photo by Richard Burkhart of the Savannah Morning News.
   Ever since Mayor Otis Johnson threw out the innuendo that the four white members of council might be racist because they were upset that DiGiovanni (the only white City Manager candidate) did not make the cut (even though he scored highest in approval from city employees and citizens), the entire debate over the city manager search has been cloaked in a thick fog of racism. 

   I saw intelligent discussions about the debacle in City Hall turn to "what organizations is he a member of?" and "could he be this?" and "might he be that?!".  It was disheartening, because I felt that the Mayor was just giving us a rubber ball to play with while he wrapped up things out of the spotlight.  It is a curious thing to watch council vote on issues that are divided down racial lines.  It gives one that feeling of "what IS going on here?" but as I have said many times in the past, nothing mucks something up like crying racism on your opponent.  It masks the true issue at hand.  While I still think the main punishable offenses against our local government are the shenanigans behind closed doors (which the City Attorney apparently knows nothing about), the sub-par bond on our Acting City Manager, and the mysterious "no comment"s, a quote from the Mayor in today's paper has really brought me down.  A claim of racism cannot be made solely based on someone's affiliations, or suggestions.  I have said before, the only way you can get away with calling someone a racist is if they stand up and admit that they are one.  Well, Mr. Mayor?

The opportunity to hire a new city manager presented two opportunities, the mayor said. The first was finding someone who would carry on the tradition of fiscal responsibility set by Don Mendonsa and Brown.
The second was that the search would break one of the remaining racial barriers in the city by allowing "a person who looks like me," to be hired, Johnson said.
The two goals are not competing, he said, because there are people who look like him who are qualified to manage the city.
"I don't apologize for it. I have no reason to apologize for it," the mayor said. "I said it, and I'm saying it again."
As he finished, several people in the audience murmured support.


   So one of your criteria is that the new City Manager "looks like [you]"?  Now, he could mean that the new City Manager needs to be skinny and bald, but I am pragmatic - not naive.  What we have just been given, in this modern era, is a politician saying outright that he wants a person in one of the highest positions in the city chosen based on skin color.  Let's apply my simple "Racism Test" to this one.  The test really is easy, and you don't have to download it.  Take anything that anyone says, and imagine a 1960's small-town white politician saying it.  Let it cook in your brain for a few seconds, take it out before it starts to burn, and Viola!  Racism!

   I am so deeply ashamed of you, Mr. Mayor.  I am ashamed because I actually debated people telling them not to follow your candy trail of racist innuendo - telling them it would only make it more difficult to seek justice against you for the corrupt way you have handled this search.  I am ashamed because you just (in some self-legitimizing way) proved them right.  What you also did was justify to any racist white person yet another reason they should not trust black people, instead of trying to set an example to educate them as to why black people are no worse than them.  What you are doing to black youth is telling them that they deserve to be hired because they were blessed with darker skin.  The people who look up to you as an inspiration are the ones to which you are saying "it's OK to favor people with the same skin color as you".  

   You are a disgrace, Mr. Mayor, to the generation of black people who fought for racial equality.  Equality is the keyword there.  You are a disgrace to the words of Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr.  You bask in his glory, but your actions go against everything he gave his life for - that white people and black people would work together.  Your notion that a City Manager must have great credentials, wonderful work history, vast experience, OH, and black skin, is downright shameful!  Whatever you once were, Mr. Mayor, you are now the type of person that a future generation fighting for equality will use as an example of what types of people have no place in a position of power!  

   I know this is long-winded, it is only because no type of person infuriates me more than someone who thinks their "race" is better than another.  It is the most debased form of human thought that exists.  You need to have a catharsis very soon, Mayor Johnson.  I feel badly for people who think the way you do, especially people who are educated. 

   What has been said from the beginning holds true still; the City Manager search MUST begin again from scratch.  There is no defensible reason why that should not occur.  This is not a basis made on all I have just said of Otis Johnson, rather to all of the posts I have made from the start.  Otis Johnson will need to find it within himself in his own personal time to contemplate his words and actions.  In the meantime, let everyone else focus on doing what is right for the city's future.

Saturday, January 29, 2011

Things Heating Up for Big Otis and Small-Toney

   This has certainly been an eventful week in Savannah, filled with the types of events that remind us all why we want our elected officials to be truthful and honest - it takes less time for them to explain what is going on.

   Due to an abandonment of honesty, we as citizens now get to stand back and try to figure out what is going on without the aid of the must crucial qualification of a good relationship - trust.  Maybe no official in the entire city of Savannah knew that Small-Toney did not have a bond while acting as city manager.  Maybe no one knew she was denied a bond when she tried to procure one - but Small-Toney knew.  So why did she keep quiet about it?  Maybe she didn't know she was required to have one, but should someone so unfamiliar with the city's charter be in a position of absolute financial power?  Maybe city council really did call that mystery secret Wednesday meeting as a continuation of the public Tuesday meeting, and every citizen in the city was so busy Wednesday that no one showed up, and *inhale* maybe the candidates, mayor and council really did not find it odd that no one was there to see the presentations *whew*!  But none of that matters now.  Since all of these trustworthy individuals have narrowed the candidates down to two (including Small-Toney), Mayor Johnson has finally pinpointed the problem.  A spoiler: it's obviously racism.  {epic article here}.

"It's very interesting, now that the white candidate has been eliminated, all of a sudden it's an issue."   -Mayor Otis Johnson

White, allegedly racist councilman Tony Thomas and validly corrupt Mayor Johnson exchange loving glances.  Original photo by Richard Burkhart of the Savannah Morning News.
 

   Actually, Mr. Mayor, I believe it became an issue because of everything I mentioned prior to that quote, but we expect no less of you.  Remember that scene in "Chicago" where she is about to go on trial for murder, and Richard Gere does a little musical number explaining that she should just "give 'em the old razzle dazzle" and basically turns the trial into a circus?  This is the same theory, except our circus is racist.  

   According to that article, white members of city council are racists because they voted for the only white candidate, who did not end up in the final two.  The reason for voting for him could be summed up by paraphrasing: "Well, all of them are horrible, but this guy is the least horrible and has the longest track record of being not horrible."  If we can assume the four white council members are not racists, then we can deduce that makes perfect sense.  The other popular notion is that the black council members have wanted a black city manager all along.  All of this, of course, is childish lunacy.  It focuses us on a sensational topic, rather than focusing on WHO is about to be given the city's blank checkbook.  

   But since Otis started it, allow me to chime in.  Last week, I read a disturbing quote from a citizen attending the public questioning forum for the candidates.  That citizen asked Small-Toney (in reference to her bonding issue) something along the lines of "when are you going to get this issue resolved so we can have our first black female city manager?" (not ver-batim, sorry I could not find my link to that quote).  The problem here is this: our elected officials should be more to us than skin-deep.  The election itself should not be what makes history more so than the policies that elected official carries out.  The fact that someone, anyone out there in Savannah wants Small-Toney elected just so we can say we made history based on the color of her skin and gender, while overlooking the fiasco of the month, is frightening to me.  A little background here:

   In my hometown of Greenwood, Mississippi, our previous mayor made history.  She was not only the first female to win the election, but she was the first black female to win the mayoral race in Greenwood, Mississippi's history.  That is a history-making double header!  Alas, she made history in three ways once you tack on the fact that she was the most inept, non-functioning, always-absent (dare I say) terrible mayor in Greenwood's recent history.  It seems to me that if a person is going to make history, that is obviously a good thing; just wait until the best-qualified history-maker comes along and vote for that person.  If the best choice happens to be non-history-making (i.e. middle-aged white guy) then maybe we need to sit back and wonder if we want to make history with the wrong person, and make progress and wealth with the right one.  I make that assessment "the right one" not because that is personally how I feel about Digiovanni (the white guy), rather, it is based on the fact that he had the most positive response after the public was allowed to question the candidates.  

   Well, up until now the elected higher-ups of the city have been making a royal mess of the kitchen, and now Mom wants to know what the hell has been going on!  Yes, the Georgia Attorney General now has this Savannah fiasco on his radar.  More to come, so stay tuned.  Don't miss out on the corruption and racism.  It sadly seems to be what we expect to read about each morning.

Friday, January 21, 2011

A Rochelle Small-Toney Time Machine

Here is an article from Savannah Morning News written by Leslie Conn and printed April 23, 2010.

Small-Toney choice for interim city manager


The offer has been made; the formal acceptance is pending.
Savannah City Council members Thursday asked Assistant City Manager Rochelle Small-Toney, director of the Bureau of Public Development, to move up a rung as interim city manager effective May 3.
As several council members called her to the podium to give her answer, Mayor Otis Johnson intervened, saying he and Small-Toney needed to meet before she gave her acceptance.
City Manager Michael Brown has resigned to become county manager in Arlington, Va.
Small-Toney's acceptance is expected, as evidenced by the city staffers who congratulated her outside council chambers and offered their assistance to her.
Under the city charter, council names an interim for three months. Council will review Small-Toney's work, and as long as everything is satisfactory, Johnson said, her position can be renewed again at six months.
Council will work as quickly as it can to organize a national search and find candidates, he said.
"We will speed it up as best we can," he said. "I do not think (her serving as interim) will go on for a third term."
Officers of the council, which includes Johnson, Mayor Pro Tem Edna Jackson, Council Chairman Tony Thomas and Vice Chairman Van Johnson, will develop a plan for a candidate search and develop a work plan for the interim months.
Small-Toney will have input, and the full council will formally adopt the work plan, he said.
She has served as assistant city manager for three years, overseeing Economic Development, Property Maintenance, Housing, Neighborhood Services, Community Planning, Development Services and similar offices.
Small-Toney, 53, previously worked as an assistant city manager in Charlottesville and Danville, Va. She has a master's degree in public administration and a bachelor's in political science from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.